Unfunded Mandates in South African Local Government: The Financial and Administrative Burden on Municipalities
To read the full presentation, click here
South African municipalities are under increasing pressure as they shoulder unfunded or underfunded mandates—services delegated by provincial governments without the necessary financial backing. This has led to mounting fiscal and administrative burdens across the country’s local governments, with some of the largest municipalities reporting severe budget shortfalls.
The issue affects a range of essential services, including healthcare, housing, library operations, and public transport. Municipalities such as Cape Town and eThekwini are among the hardest hit, facing funding gaps reaching into the billions. Cape Town alone has reported a shortfall of R2.5 billion related to services it is mandated to provide without sufficient national or provincial funding.
The problem stems from a misalignment between legislative responsibilities and fiscal allocations. Local governments are expected to implement services that are legally under provincial jurisdiction, yet the corresponding budgets often do not follow. Legislative frameworks, including the Government Immovable Asset Management Act (GIAMA), further complicate matters by limiting municipalities’ ability to manage infrastructure they do not own.
Efforts by the National Treasury to address these challenges—through reviews in 2016 and 2022, and sector-specific dialogues—have yielded limited results. Despite acknowledging the scale of the problem, these initiatives have not translated into lasting policy or funding reforms.
Rising operational costs, particularly in metropolitan areas, are adding to the strain. Municipalities report that staffing costs and service delivery demands are growing faster than the available grant funding. This forces many local governments to redirect funds from service delivery to cover basic administrative expenses.
Policy proposals currently on the table include full financial transfers for mandated services, the establishment of equitable funding frameworks, and constitutional reforms to better align responsibilities with available resources. Analysts and stakeholders agree that a coordinated, multi-stakeholder approach will be essential to making progress.
The ongoing crisis underscores the urgent need for systemic reform. Without decisive action, municipalities may struggle to maintain basic services, threatening broader social and economic stability. Ensuring financial and legislative alignment, while preserving service delivery, is now a critical task for all spheres of government.
